folgekosten.vergleich
ENLanguage

Complication insurance compared

The full detailed analysis of the current complication insurance tariffs (Folgekostentarife) – beautyprotect LITE, PRO and VIP, medassure beauty and safe4beauty. Prepared and reviewed by Gehling Consulting – independent actuaries (Versicherungsmathematiker, Aktuare) – on behalf of quadmed AG, based on the official policy terms and conditions.

Published
July 2026
Last updated
27 July 2026
Data as of
June 2026

This is a translation of the German original. In case of any discrepancy, the German version of this comparison and the insurers' own policy terms and conditions (AVB) are authoritative. Insurance terminology is jurisdiction-specific; German legal terms are given in brackets where an exact English equivalent does not exist.

What does complication insurance cover?

Complication insurance (Folgekostenversicherung) covers treatment costs arising from complications after cosmetic surgery – for example after a breast augmentation, liposuction or rhinoplasty. The most important building block: statutory health insurers are permitted to reclaim treatment costs from the patient in the event of complications following aesthetic procedures (recourse claim (Regress) under § 52 SGB V) – complication insurance assumes this claim up to EUR 300,000, and with beautyprotect VIP up to EUR 500,000. Higher-tier tariffs additionally pay for private follow-up treatment by the surgeon who originally operated or in a private clinic, on both an outpatient and an inpatient basis. Individual tariffs even cover corrections that are not medically necessary, for example in the case of objective aesthetic impairments such as raised scars or displaced implants. By contrast, purely subjective dissatisfaction with the result is not insured with almost all providers. Table 1 shows what the individual tariffs provide in detail.

1 Overview

Complication insurance covers treatment costs that are medically necessary as a result of complications following cosmetic surgery or another aesthetic procedure. Depending on the insurance status – covered by GKV, holding substitutive PKV cover, or entitled to civil servants' health subsidy (Beihilfe) – costs of differing amounts are not assumed by the health insurance provider. The basis for this consists of statutory provisions in the GKV (SGB V § 52), standardised rules on Beihilfe in the various Beihilfe regulations, and the individual agreements in private health insurance.

Even where the medically necessary treatment can be carried out within regular healthcare provision, many patients prefer to be treated further by the doctor who originally treated them. However, that doctor as a rule invoices on a private basis only. The higher-tier tariffs of complication insurance policies also cover this private treatment, whether outpatient or inpatient.

In addition, treatment costs may arise if the result does not turn out as would be subjectively or objectively desirable and corrective treatment is to be carried out. This service, which is not medically necessary, is only offered on a purely private basis outside general healthcare provision. Complication insurance policies in some cases also assume the costs of these non-necessary corrective treatments, e.g. after accidents or if objectively significant aesthetic impairments are present.

This comparison of complication insurance policies describes the tariffs currently on offer — June 2026. The focus of the tariffs is on classic cosmetic surgery in the narrower sense, such as breast augmentation with an implant. Aesthetic treatments such as wrinkle tightening, Botox treatments and so on can in some cases be covered by separate tariffs, even though they are covered by the complication insurance policies considered here. The latter tariffs for "small" treatments are not considered further here.

Section 2 assesses the strength of the benefits offered by the tariffs and summarises this in a rating. Section 3 contains detailed information on the tariffs in tabular form.

1.1 Selection of tariffs

Since the last publication of the comparison in spring 2023, the complication insurance policies on offer have developed further. With "medassure beauty", distributed by the managing general agent (Assekuradeur) JHC Cologne and underwritten by Nürnberger Krankenversicherung, a satisfaction guarantee can be taken out again from 2024, although as a supplementary accident insurance policy to be taken out separately with Dialog Versicherung AG. In addition to the two familiar tariffs, Squarelife Insurance AG has launched a further tariff, "beautyprotect VIP", with higher sums insured. "safe4beauty" has been offered since 2025 by the insurer W. R. Berkley Europe AG – Niederlassung für Deutschland, and in the course of the change of insurer the policy was revised in many details. All the insurance policies are offered mainly through specialised brokers, which have remained unchanged for years. The tariffs considered are: "beautyprotect LITE", "beautyprotect PRO" and "beautyprotect VIP" from Squarelife Insurance AG, "medassure beauty" from Nürnberger Krankenversicherung AG together with "medassure beHappy" from Dialog Versicherung AG, and "safe4beauty" from W. R. Berkley Europe AG – Niederlassung für Deutschland.

The quality of the tariffs has improved overall; the associated documents — AVB and IPID — are now also predominantly easy to understand.

The data status is June 2026.

1.2 Data basis

The comparison of complication insurance policies is based on the contractual agreements as set out in the general terms and conditions (Allgemeine Versicherungsbedingungen, AVB) and further information material such as the insurance product information document (IPID). In individual cases, additional information material from the providers' websites is used, e.g. on the level of the maximum sum insured or the possible policy terms, or the details given in the insurance policy documents (Versicherungsscheine).

1.3 Structure of the comparison

The tariffs are described in the five areas "product design", "scope of cover", "exclusions", "policyholder duties (Obliegenheiten)" and "further AVB provisions". "Product design" describes the type of insurance and key framework conditions such as the policy term, maximum entry age, number of insured procedures and the geographical scope of validity. "Scope of cover" contains the central promise of cover, i.e. up to what amount and in which cases the complication insurance pays. Exclusions and policyholder duties are classic risk-limiting provisions on the part of the insurers.

Because of the complexity of the subject matter, a presentation that is both complete and compact is unfortunately not possible. In order to provide an overview, Table 1 therefore contains a summary of the most important aspects of the tariffs. To improve clarity, the tariffs "beautyprotect VIP" and "medassure beHappy" are not presented separately. On the one hand, because "beautyprotect VIP" is identical in cover to "beautyprotect PRO" apart from the sums insured. On the other hand, because "medassure beHappy" offers only a small additional cover in the event of subjective dissatisfaction, in the guise of a supplementary accident insurance policy.

This overview is suitable for quick orientation. In addition, Table 3 contains further details on the range of benefits, the exclusions, policyholder duties and other aspects. This table provides a comprehensive overview and also addresses points of detail.

1.4 Exclusions in detail

As different as the tariffs are in what they pay, so different are their exclusions – often more decisive for the choice of tariff than the sum insured. All providers exclude subjective dissatisfaction with the surgical result. Squarelife (beautyprotect) works with few, abstractly worded exclusions such as pre-existing conditions or third-party liability (Dritthaftung). medassure beauty excludes, among other things, capsular contracture (Kapselfibrose) grades 1 and 2, Breast Illness Syndrome and treatments outside the countries named in the insurance policy document. safe4beauty has the longest list: in addition to capsular contracture grades 1 and 2, also scars, sensory disturbances, numbness, hair loss with facelifts and blindness with eyelid lifts. Important for women with breast implants: only beautyprotect PRO/VIP insures capsular contracture of all Baker grades. The complete exclusion lists of all four tariffs can be found in Table 1 and Table 3.

Table 1: Summary comparison of complication insurance policies

Scroll sideways to see all providers

Tariffbeautyprotect LITEbeautyprotect PRO / VIP*medassure beautysafe4beauty
ProviderSquarelife Insurance AG, LiechtensteinSquarelife Insurance AG, LiechtensteinNürnberger Krankenversicherung AG, NurembergW. R. Berkley Europe AG – Niederlassung für Deutschland, Cologne
Intermediary / managing general agent (Assekuradeur)quadmed AG, Liechtensteinquadmed AG, LiechtensteinJHC Service GmbH, Cologne4beauty Assekuranzmakler GmbH, Cologne
Product designsupplementary health insurance (Krankenzusatzversicherung) with automatic renewalsupplementary health insurance with automatic renewalsupplementary health insurance with a fixed termaccident insurance (Unfallversicherung) with a fixed term
Cover for aesthetic procedures already carried out possibleyesyesnono
optional benefit extensions (see the notes in the footnotes)beautyprotect VIP*medassure beHappy****
Scope of validitycosmetic surgery worldwide, follow-up treatment in Europecosmetic surgery worldwide, follow-up treatment in Europeas per insurance policy document, naming the treating doctorcosmetic surgery in selected countries, naming the treating doctor; complication treatment in Germany or the country where the procedure was carried out
Scope of cover
Assumption of costs for medically necessary treatments as a result of an aesthetic operation
Recourse claim under § 52 (2) SGB V for GKV membersyesyesyesyes
Assumption of costs for private doctor or private clinic (outside standard statutory care (Regelversorgung))noyesyesyes
In detail
Assumption of costs for outpatient treatment (statutory health insurance accreditation (Kassenzulassung) / standard statutory care)GKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000; GKV co-payments (Zuzahlungen); PKV deductible (Selbstbehalt)GKV recourse up to EUR 300,000 / EUR 500,000*; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000 / EUR 500,000*; GKV co-payments; PKV deductibleGKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 10,000, up to EUR 5,000 if the doctor is changed**GKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000
Assumption of costs for outpatient treatment by a private doctor (outside standard statutory care)noup to EUR 30,000 / EUR 50,000*, payments up to the level of a flat-rate amount*up to EUR 10,000, up to EUR 5,000 if the doctor is changed**up to EUR 10,000 with cost estimate (Kostenvoranschlag)***
Assumption of costs for inpatient treatment in a public hospitalGKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000; GKV co-payments; PKV deductible; optional hospital services (Wahlleistungen)GKV recourse up to EUR 300,000 / EUR 500,000*; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000 / EUR 500,000*; GKV co-payments; PKV deductible; optional hospital servicesGKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000GKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000
Assumption of costs for inpatient treatment in a private clinic (not a public hospital)noup to EUR 30,000 / EUR 50,000*, payments up to the level of a flat-rate amount*up to EUR 10,000, up to EUR 5,000 if the clinic is changed**up to EUR 10,000 with cost estimate***
Assumption of costs for treatments that are NOT medically necessary
Assumption of costs for private medical treatment or private clinicnoup to EUR 30,000 / EUR 50,000* in the case of objective aesthetic impairment*, "accident cover", "cover in the event of breast cancer"up to EUR 10,000 for the benefit modules "Ästhetik Plus" and "Unfall-Schutz"**up to EUR 10,000 for the restoration of the original surgical result within the scope of a covered complication treatment***
further benefitstravel costs up to EUR 300; examination/biopsy costs for capsular contracture
Optionsbeautyprotect VIP: variant of beautyprotect PRO with increased sums insured and flat-rate amounts*medassure beHappy: benefits also in the event of subjective dissatisfaction via supplementary accident insurance****
Further points
indirect complication as a result of cosmetic surgery insured (e.g. accident-related consequences)yesyes"Unfall-Schutz" moduleno (accident-related consequences insured according to the website, however)
Cover for capsular contractureif medically necessary, as a rule at grade 4grades 1 to 4grades 3 and 4grades 3 and 4
Conditions for benefitscomplication during the policy termcomplication during the policy termtreatment in the country stated in the insurance policy document; restricted sum insured if the doctor/clinic is changed; insured event of the complication within one year (or the period stated in the insurance policy document) after the procedure, treatment duration a maximum of 2 years, longer with the insurer's approvalcost estimate, which must be approved for plannable treatments (not for emergency treatment and not for treatments in a public hospital); start of treatment of the complication within 3 months of notification, treatment duration a maximum of 12 months
Exclusions for complications (selection)• pre-existing conditions, but underwriting (Risikoprüfung) at application stage
• no medically clear and unexpected cause identifiable
• subjective dissatisfaction
• third-party liability
• age-related disorder
• consequences of chronic illnesses
• pre-existing conditions, but underwriting at application stage
• no medically clear and unexpected cause identifiable
• subjective dissatisfaction
• third-party liability
• age-related disorder
• consequences of chronic illnesses
• consequences of a change in shape due to connective tissue weakness / dents or irregularities after liposuction (Fettabsaugung / Liposuktion)
• medical malpractice or treatment errors (Kunst- oder Behandlungsfehler)
• treatments in a country not named in the insurance policy document
• subjective dissatisfaction, but can additionally be covered on a limited basis via "medassure beHappy"
• patients with an existing diagnosis of capsular contracture: no insurability possible (according to the website, 5 June 2026)
• complications attributable to product liability
• self-inflicted injuries
• intentional acts
• capsular contracture 1 and 2
• procedures before the start of cover
• mental illness, depression, Breast Illness Syndrome
• medical malpractice or treatment errors
• complications that heal without medical treatment
• subjective dissatisfaction
• breast augmentation: no insurance possible for persons who have already suffered capsular contracture
• product liability (implant costs a maximum of EUR 600 if a warranty claim is rejected)
• self-inflicted injuries
• criminal offences
• capsular contracture 1 and 2
• scars
• asymmetries and deteriorations in shape; these are, however, insured where they result from a pathological change that is visually impairing
Policyholder duties (Obliegenheiten) (selection)• the insured event must be notified without undue delay
• documents to be submitted: medical treatment, invoice or health insurer's benefits statement
• the insured event must be notified without undue delay
• documents to be submitted: medical treatment, invoice or health insurer's benefits statement
• duty to notify treatments in text form or by telephone
• submit the GKV / PKV reimbursement demand notice (Rückforderungsbescheid) without undue delay
• presentation of the health insurance card for GKV members
• duty to notify a complication, at the latest before a procedure (in writing)
• submit a cost estimate
• presentation of the reimbursement demand notice or of the PKV / Beihilfe rejection
• assertion of warranty claims against implant manufacturers
Start of coverfrom the date the contract is concluded or the agreed start of coverfrom the date the contract is concluded or the agreed start of coveras per the insurance policy document, usually the day of the procedure, at the earliest upon payment of the first or single premiumday of the procedure
Duration of cover for complicationsopen-ended, minimum one year and maximum up to the age of 80open-ended, minimum one year and maximum up to the age of 8012 months or as agreed; according to the website up to three treatments and a term of 5 years12, 24 or 36 months
Premium paymentpayment as agreed, thereafter in accordance with the agreed payment method on the due date upon renewalpayment as agreed, thereafter in accordance with the agreed payment method on the due date upon renewalpayment within 14 days; in the event of withdrawal by the insurer due to non-payment of premium, 20 % administration fee (Geschäftsgebühr)payment no later than 14 days after the insured procedure
Basis of comparison: AVB (as at) and customer information, websiteAVB beautyprotect LITE (as at 07.2025)AVB beautyprotect PRO (as at 07.2025), AVB beautyprotect VIP (as at 07.2025)AVB medassure beauty (as at 07.2023), AUB medassure beHappy (as at 02.2024), IPID: website (as at 5 June 2026)AVB safe4beauty (as at 01.2025 DE)

*: beautyprotect PRO / VIP — explanation of the case-based flat-rate amount: For private invoices under the GOÄ and for treatment in private clinics, Squarelife Insurance AG provides for treatment costs to be covered by means of case-based flat-rate amounts; see also Annex C: Schedule: Catalogue of private medical services in the beautyprotect PRO / VIP AVB. These flat-rate amounts simplify billing for treatments due to a complication following cosmetic surgery. The level of the flat-rate amounts was derived on the basis of Squarelife Insurance AG's extensive experience of more than 12,000 claims. The flat-rate amounts range from EUR 250 for the simplest treatments up to EUR 5,000 for complex treatments. Multiple payments of the treatment flat rate are also made if several treatments are required, up to the agreed sum insured of EUR 30,000 or EUR 50,000. The most frequent complications are named explicitly. Further possible procedures are captured, for example, via the duration of a treatment, the necessity of a general anaesthetic, or the length of an inpatient stay. Clinics and doctors can either bill the flat rate directly or prepare a classic itemised statement under the scale of fees for doctors (Gebührenordnung für Ärzte, GOÄ), which is then, however, settled only up to the listed flat rate. On the basis of experience, the flat-rate amounts are set such that reasonable invoices are generously covered, while excessive invoices remain outside the scope. The flat-rate amounts are regularly reviewed for appropriateness and are also increased for existing customers. It makes sense to agree these flat-rate amounts with the treating doctor in advance.
An aesthetic impairment exists, for example, in the case of raised scars, double bubble, rotation, dislocation or bottoming out of an implant.
beautyprotect VIP: the sum insured in standard statutory care is EUR 500,000 instead of EUR 300,000, and for private clinics and private practices EUR 50,000 instead of EUR 30,000. The case-based flat-rate amounts are doubled compared with "beautyprotect PRO".

**: medassure beauty: The agreed benefits of "medassure beauty" are documented in the insurance policy document and are not contained in the body of terms and conditions. The details given here are taken from the IPID and the website, in particular the limitation of benefits to EUR 5,000 if the doctor / clinic is changed (website / FAQ accessed on 5 June 2026). According to the IPID, benefit catalogues are also possible with "medassure beauty". "medassure beauty" also pays in the event of complications resulting from dental treatment and dental prostheses.

***: safe4beauty: for treatments abroad the sum insured is EUR 10,000 and, in addition, a catalogue of treatment flat rates is firmly agreed; see AVB 4.4.

****: medassure beHappy: supplementary accident insurance with additional cover in the event of subjective dissatisfaction with the surgical result, with a benefit level of a maximum of EUR 2,000. In addition, the usual benefits of a supplementary accident insurance policy with a sum insured of EUR 20,000 and a death benefit of EUR 10,000. The insurer is Dialog Versicherung AG, Munich.

2 Assessment of the complication insurance tariffs

The decisive factors for the strength of a tariff's benefits are the scope and limits of the insurance cover as well as the level of the sums insured. The area "scope of cover" therefore carries the greatest weight in the overall assessment, at 50 %.

Also relevant are aspects such as cover for past procedures as well, the insurance duration — that is, the period over which complication costs following an aesthetic procedure are assumed —, possible benefit extensions, and the geographical reach of the cover. This "product design" (insurance duration, freely chosen point of conclusion, several procedures, direct linkage to a planned procedure, countries of a procedure or of the follow-up treatment) is weighted at 20 %.

Exclusions account for 20 % of the overall assessment, and the policyholder duties and further provisions 5 % each. Policyholder duties such as a mandatory cost estimate, which have a strong influence on the insurance cover, are taken into account in the area "scope of cover".

2.1 Notes on the individual rating criteria

2.1.1 Product design

Squarelife Insurance AG has revised the existing tariffs "beautyprotect LITE" and "beautyprotect PRO" in certain respects and designed the new tariff "beautyprotect VIP" with significantly higher sums insured and case-based flat-rate amounts, but otherwise identically. Key features such as an ongoing supplementary health insurance policy with monthly automatic renewal are still included. This approach considerably simplifies dealing with complication insurance, especially as aesthetic procedures already carried out before the contract was concluded also fall under the cover. Insured persons do not have to worry about whether planned procedures are covered or whether complications only occur after one or more years. There are also few geographical restrictions.

Nürnberger Krankenversicherung with "medassure beauty" and W. R. Berkley Europe AG – Niederlassung für Deutschland with "safe4beauty" offer a classic complication insurance policy that is tied to one or more specific procedures with a firmly agreed insurance duration. For example, the type of procedure and also the treating doctor or the clinic are asked for in the insurance application. According to its website, "medassure beauty" offers generous insurance durations of up to five years. In addition, cosmetic surgery and complication treatment can, by agreement, also take place abroad. "safe4beauty" has newly included the possibility for the cosmetic surgery to be carried out in selected foreign countries. Any complication treatment must then take place in Germany or in the country of the cosmetic surgery.

The approaches of the three providers differ in this respect. The "beautyprotect" tariffs generally cover the complication costs of further possible procedures as well, without the type of procedure or the surgeon being known at that point. The other providers offer cover for precisely defined operations and request the necessary details in the insurance application. This information can then feed into the underwriting and also into the pricing.

There are also relevant differences in the period within which follow-up treatment after a complication must be started and completed.

2.1.2 Scope of cover

Of the tariffs considered, "beautyprotect LITE" from Squarelife Insurance AG is the only one that does not assume private medical costs outside standard statutory care. The cover is essentially limited to possible GKV recourse claims as well as costs not assumed under PKV or Beihilfe. In this respect this tariff is genuinely a "lite" tariff and cannot be compared with the other tariffs. For this reason, no assessment is made for "beautyprotect LITE" in the category of insurance cover.

In all the other tariffs, private medical costs for medically necessary follow-up treatments are assumed on an outpatient or inpatient basis, in some cases after the regular health insurance cover has paid first. This is the central benefit module. Differences exist in the sum insured and hence in the level of cost assumption for a private doctor's invoice or clinic invoice, and in the billing arrangements. Squarelife Insurance AG has introduced a system of flat-rate amounts for private treatments, which can be billed directly by the doctors or clinics taking account of the scale of fees for doctors (GOÄ). Flat-rate billing simplifies and speeds up the billing process. With its increased sums insured, "beautyprotect VIP" is aimed at specialised and demanding doctors and clinics that charge significantly higher fees than is normally the case.

"medassure beauty" limits the sums insured to EUR 5,000 if the doctor or the clinic for the complication treatment is changed, compared with the usual sum insured of EUR 10,000. This possibly reflects the approach already mentioned, namely that a specific treatment with a specific doctor is insured. Cost reimbursement in outpatient standard statutory care is also limited to EUR 10,000 for private patients and persons entitled to Beihilfe.

For serious complications, the patient's existing insurance cover typically takes effect first, and the complication insurance policies then assume, on a subsidiary basis, costs of a clinic that have not been covered. In these cases, high sums insured of EUR 300,000 are generally customary, and with "beautyprotect PRO" even EUR 500,000.

When it comes to assuming treatments that are not medically necessary, Squarelife takes its own customer-friendly approach and also insures objective aesthetic impairments. These include, for example, raised scars, double bubble, rotation, dislocation or bottoming out of an implant. Even if other providers were to be generous in individual cases where treatments are not medically necessary, the explicit contractual provision at Squarelife creates considerably greater legal certainty for insured persons and reduces the potential for conflict.

With all providers, any consequences of accidents are insured to the extent that, if medically necessary treatment is required, the "restoration of the original surgical result" is also covered. With "medassure beauty" and "safe4beauty" these are included benefit modules; with the "beautyprotect" tariffs this already forms part of the core promise.

"Filler treatments" and the like are regulated fairly extensively and separately by W. R. Berkley Europe with "safe4beauty".

"beautyprotect PRO" and "VIP" newly include a benefit for "breast reconstruction after breast cancer". In the case of breast cancer, breast reconstructions are co-insured which are not medically necessary and are therefore not assumed by the health insurer, e.g. for the second, unaffected breast. This cover is, however, subject to a waiting period of two years after the contract is concluded.

Before assuming the costs of a complication treatment, "safe4beauty" from W. R. Berkley Europe is the only tariff to require a cost estimate for treatment in a private clinic or private practice, which must be approved. Through this approval requirement, the insurer has, with this tariff, a means of intervening in the costs of a follow-up treatment. Unfortunately, no further details on how a cost estimate is handled can be found. Both "medassure beauty" and "safe4beauty" generally limit cost reimbursement in private billing to 3.5 times the GOÄ multiplier factor (Steigerungsfaktor).

2.1.3 Exclusions

The tariffs of Squarelife Insurance AG ("beautyprotect LITE", "PRO" and "VIP") as well as "medassure beauty" from Nürnberger Krankenversicherung work with a comparatively manageable catalogue of exclusions. Squarelife lists exclusions that are worded rather abstractly; Nürnberger Krankenversicherung with "medassure beauty" lists few specific medical exclusions or some general circumstances. "safe4beauty" from W. R. Berkley Europe, by contrast, lists a considerably more extensive series of possible complications that are excluded from cover. For filler treatments there are again separate additional exclusions.

Squarelife insures capsular contracture irrespective of the Baker grade; "medassure beauty" and "safe4beauty" exclude Baker grades 1 and 2. Until now, a biopsy has been required as evidence of capsular contracture. "safe4beauty" explicitly assumes the examination costs of a biopsy and newly also permits evidence of capsular contracture by means of a mammogram. "safe4beauty" also limits the costs of an implant where a warranty claim actually exists.

2.1.4 Policyholder duties

For a valid claim to benefits, the insured person must fulfil the agreed policyholder duties. In addition to the usual and familiar duties such as correct statements in the application, complication insurance policies in particular include duties to inform the insurers in the event of a claim. In general, an insured event must be notified to the insurer without undue delay. The already mentioned assertion of warranty claims against implant manufacturers at W. R. Berkley Europe is found indirectly in the exclusions of third-party liability in the other tariffs. With the obligation under "safe4beauty" from W. R. Berkley Europe to submit a cost estimate and have it approved, this insurer stands alone.

2.1.5 Further provisions

"safe4beauty" permits premium payment after the cosmetic surgery, provided the contract was concluded in good time beforehand. "medassure beauty" can be supplemented by "medassure beHappy" with a small benefit in the event of subjective dissatisfaction.

2.2 Advantages and disadvantages of the individual tariffs

The following points count positively in the benefits assessment:

  • extensive insurance cover: GKV recourse, benefits in standard statutory care, private medical billing in a private practice or private clinic, cover for treatments that are not medically necessary
  • high sums insured for private medical billing
  • conditions for benefits and policyholder duties limited to important and customary aspects
  • long insurance durations and cover for past operations
  • treatment by the head physician and single/twin rooms in hospital (optional hospital services)
  • few exclusions
  • cosmetic surgery and complication treatments also possible outside Germany

The following are correspondingly counted as disadvantages:

  • low sums insured for private medical billing
  • written cost estimate
  • wide-ranging exclusions of medical side effects
  • restriction on the reimbursement of medication costs
  • cover only for medically necessary treatments
  • restrictive provisions for treatments abroad
  • short periods for carrying out a complication treatment

Table 2: Advantages / disadvantages and assessment of the complication insurance policies considered

Scroll sideways to see all providers

Advantages / disadvantagesbeautyprotect LITEbeautyprotect PRO / VIP*medassure beautysafe4beauty
Advantages• cover for indirect complications, e.g. due to an accident
• few specific exclusions
• any procedures during the policy term are co-insured, minimum term 1 year, thereafter cancellable monthly
• conclusion and cover still possible after an aesthetic procedure
• aesthetic procedures possible worldwide, complication treatment in Europe
• sum insured for private medical services up to EUR 30,000 or EUR 50,000*
• treatment and cost reimbursement also for procedures that are not medically necessary (objective impairment, e.g. capsular contracture grades 1 and 2); this also implies the "restoration of the original surgical result"
• cover for indirect complications, e.g. due to an accident
• few specific exclusions
• any procedures during the policy term are co-insured, minimum term 1 year, thereafter cancellable monthly
• conclusion and cover still possible after an aesthetic procedure
• aesthetic procedures possible worldwide, complication treatment in Europe
• PKV: assumption of acute hospital costs up to EUR 300,000
• assumption of the costs of a treatment with simultaneous restoration of the original result, if an insured event exists; "Unfall-Schutz"
• aesthetic procedures and complication treatment also outside Germany by agreement
• assumption of costs in standard statutory care up to EUR 300,000, outpatient and inpatient
• assumption of the costs of a treatment with simultaneous restoration of the original result, if an insured event exists; "Unfall-Schutz" according to the website
• premium payment also possible up to 14 days after the procedure
• aesthetic procedures and complication treatment also in selected European countries
Disadvantages• insurance cover only for standard statutory care (statutory health insurance accreditation)
• only medically necessary treatments
• cancellation by the insurer possible at the end of an insurance year
• case-based flat-rate amount for billing a private doctor or private clinic
• cancellation by the insurer possible at the end of an insurance year
• private medical billing up to EUR 10,000, only up to EUR 5,000 if the doctor/clinic is changed; outpatient treatments, including in standard statutory care, only up to EUR 10,000
• predominantly only medically necessary treatments
• explicit exclusion of Breast Illness Syndrome
• reimbursement of medication and prescription charges up to EUR 400
• 20 % administration fee in the event of withdrawal due to non-payment of premium
• treatment duration for a complication a maximum of 2 years
• private invoices limited to EUR 10,000, benefit limitation abroad to EUR 10,000 applying a catalogue of flat-rate benefit amounts
• predominantly only medically necessary treatments
• cost estimate mandatory for plannable treatments
• many exclusions, including explicitly illness-related ones
• written duty to notify a complication
• benefits possibly only after a conciliation procedure (Schlichtungsverfahren)
• complication treatment to be completed within 12 months
Benefits assessment (scale from to ★★★★★)
Product design (20 %)★★★★★★★★ / ★★★★★★★★★
Insurance cover and conditions for benefits (50 %)no assessment**★★★★ / ★★★★★★★★★★★
Exclusions (20 %)★★★★★★★★ / ★★★★★★★★★
Policyholder duties (5 %)★★★★★★★★ / ★★★★★★★★★★
Further provisions (5 %)★★★★★★★★ / ★★★★★★★★★★★
Overallno assessment**★★★★ (4.0) / ★★★★ (4.4)★★★ (3.1)★★★ (2.7)
Basis of comparison: AVB (as at) and customer informationAVB beautyprotect LITE (as at 07.2025)AVB beautyprotect PRO (as at 07.2025), AVB beautyprotect VIP (as at 07.2025)AVB medassure beauty (as at 07.2023), AUB medassure beHappy (as at 02.2024), IPID: website (as at 5 June 2026)AVB safe4beauty (as at 01.2025 DE)

*: beautyprotect VIP: the sums insured are significantly increased compared with beautyprotect PRO

**: With its restriction to GKV recourse, "beautyprotect LITE" forms its own product category and is therefore not comparable with the other tariffs. For this reason, no assessment is awarded for the insurance cover and no overall assessment. The other rating criteria are comparable across the tariffs.

2.3 Overall assessment

In the overall assessment, the tariffs "beautyprotect PRO" and "beautyprotect VIP" from Squarelife Insurance AG achieve the highest scores. The decisive factors are the assumption of private medical services up to EUR 30,000 with "beautyprotect PRO" and EUR 50,000 with "beautyprotect VIP", as well as the co-insurance of objective aesthetic impairments, including where these are not medically necessary. In addition, the insurance approach with annual renewal without a specific tie to an aesthetic procedure stands out positively. "beautyprotect VIP" also makes it possible to cover exclusive costs.

"medassure beauty" generally pays up to EUR 10,000 for outpatient treatment and a private clinic, and where the doctor or clinic is changed only up to EUR 5,000, but for treatments in public hospitals up to EUR 300,000 for private patients and Beihilfe. Also striking is the limitation of the reimbursement of medication and prescription charges to EUR 400. The integration of the "Unfall-Schutz" and "Ästhetik Plus" modules upgrades the tariff, since these would be treatments that are not medically necessary.

"safe4beauty" reimburses up to EUR 300,000 in standard statutory care. For private doctors and private clinics, however, a cost estimate is generally required, which has to be approved except in emergencies. How this is handled operationally is unclear. In addition, "safe4beauty" also pays for an operation that carries out the restoration of the original surgical result, and thus takes a step in the direction of treatments that are not medically necessary. According to the website, the consequences of an accident are also covered.

Among the exclusions, "safe4beauty" from W. R. Berkley Europe stands out with a comparatively very long list that names many specific medical complications. "medassure beauty" lists considerably fewer points, with only a few specific complications remaining. Squarelife Insurance AG restricts itself to rather abstract exclusions, whereby an exclusion of "third-party liability" is likely to arise most frequently. In addition, changes in shape and dents are explicitly excluded.

The further provisions differ only slightly. Worth mentioning is the generous provision on premium payment up to a point in time after the operation with "safe4beauty".

The overall assessment of "beautyprotect PRO" thus reaches four stars (4.0 points), as does "beautyprotect VIP" with four stars (4.4 points) on a scale of one to five stars. "medassure beauty" achieves 3.1 points and therefore three stars, as does "safe4beauty" with 2.7 points and three stars. "beautyprotect LITE" receives no overall assessment because its benefits are restricted to standard statutory care, even though the other provisions are comparably good to those in the "beautyprotect PRO" tariff.

beautyprotect vs. medassure – the direct comparison

The two most sought-after providers in direct comparison: beautyprotect (Squarelife) wins the 2026 rating with 4.0 (PRO) and 4.4 (VIP) out of 5 stars; medassure beauty achieves 3.1. In favour of beautyprotect are the higher sums insured for private treatments (EUR 30,000/50,000 instead of EUR 10,000), cover for procedures already carried out, the open-ended term with monthly cancellability, and cover for objective aesthetic impairments including capsular contracture of all grades. In favour of medassure are the assumption of acute hospital costs up to EUR 300,000 for private patients and the cover that can be extended by option ("beHappy" in the event of subjective dissatisfaction). Points to note with medassure: only EUR 5,000 if the doctor or clinic is changed, medication only up to EUR 400, a fixed contract per procedure. The actuaries' conclusion: anyone who wants flexible ongoing cover is better off with beautyprotect; medassure scores with one-off, precisely planned procedures.

3 Supplementary tabular overview of the current complication insurance offerings

Table 3: detailed comparison of the complication insurance policies considered

Scroll sideways to see all providers

Tariffbeautyprotect LITEbeautyprotect PRO / VIP*medassure beautysafe4beauty
InsurerSquarelife Insurance AG, LiechtensteinSquarelife Insurance AG, LiechtensteinNürnberger Krankenversicherung AG, NurembergW. R. Berkley Europe AG – Niederlassung für Deutschland, Cologne
Intermediary / managing general agent (Assekuradeur)quadmed AG, Liechtensteinquadmed AG, LiechtensteinJHC Service GmbH, Cologne4beauty Assekuranzmakler GmbH, Cologne
Product designsupplementary health insurance (Krankenzusatzversicherung) with automatic renewalsupplementary health insurance with automatic renewalsupplementary health insurance with a fixed termaccident insurance (Unfallversicherung) with a fixed term
Insurance of aesthetic procedures already carried out possibleyesyesnono
Scope of validitycosmetic surgery worldwide, follow-up treatment in Europecosmetic surgery worldwide, follow-up treatment in Europeas per insurance policy document (Versicherungsschein)cosmetic surgery in: Germany, Italy, Austria, Czech Republic, Spain, France; complication treatment in Germany or the country where the procedure was carried out
Policy term up to the age of 80 possible through automatic renewalyesyesnono
optional benefit extensionsbeautyprotect VIP*medassure beHappy****
Accident cover?indirect consequences such as accidentsindirect consequences such as accidents"Unfall-Schutz" included, also if restoration of the original surgical result is not medically necessaryyes according to the website, no explicit provision in the AVB
Insurance cover depending on the procedurenocost cover for private billing is provided on a flat-rate basis depending on the procedurethe doctor performing the cosmetic surgery and the country of treatment and of the complication treatment are specified in the insurance policy documentfor procedures abroad, flat-rate cost cover per procedure
Special provisions for "wrinkle treatments"nononofiller treatments / Botox / thread lift
Scope of cover
Assumption of costs for medically necessary treatments as a result of an aesthetic operation (overview)
Recourse claim under § 52 (2) SGB V for GKV membersyesyesyesyes
Assumption of costs for private doctor or private clinic (outside standard statutory care (Regelversorgung))noyesyesyes
Assumption of costs for optional hospital services (Wahlleistungen) such as single or twin rooms, treatment by the head physician, etc.yesyesno explicit provisioncost assumption follows the compulsory health insurance
Assumption of costs for GKV co-payments (Zuzahlungen) and PKV deductibles (Selbstbehalte)yesyesno explicit provisionno explicit provision
Assumption of costs for treatments that are NOT medically necessary
Assumption of costs for private medical treatment or private clinicnoin the case of objective aesthetic impairment*, "accident cover", "cover in the event of breast cancer"via the integrated benefit modules "Ästhetik Plus", "Unfall-Schutz"restoration of the original surgical result insured
Assumption of costs in detail – medically necessary treatments
Assumption of costs for outpatient treatment (statutory health insurance accreditation (Kassenzulassung) / standard statutory care)GKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000; GKV co-payments; PKV deductibleGKV recourse up to EUR 300,000 / EUR 500,000*; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000 / EUR 500,000*; GKV co-payments; PKV deductibleGKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 10,000, up to EUR 5,000 if the doctor is changed**; medication and prescription charges up to EUR 400; up to 3.5 times the GOÄGKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000; up to 3.5 times the GOÄ; travel costs up to EUR 300; examination/biopsy costs for capsular contracture; abroad a maximum of EUR 10,000 in total
Assumption of costs for outpatient treatment by a private doctor (outside standard statutory care)noup to EUR 30,000 / EUR 50,000*, payments up to the level of a flat-rate amount*up to EUR 10,000, up to EUR 5,000 if the doctor is changed**; medication and prescription charges up to EUR 400; up to 3.5 times the GOÄup to EUR 10,000 with cost estimate (Kostenvoranschlag)***; up to 3.5 times the GOÄ; travel costs up to EUR 300; examination/biopsy costs for capsular contracture; abroad a maximum of EUR 10,000 in total
Assumption of costs for inpatient treatment in a public hospitalGKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000; GKV co-payments; PKV deductible; head physician and single/twin roomGKV recourse up to EUR 300,000 / EUR 500,000*; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000 / EUR 500,000*; GKV co-payments; PKV deductible; head physician and single/twin roomGKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000; medication and prescription charges up to EUR 400; 3.5 times the GOÄGKV recourse up to EUR 300,000; PKV / Beihilfe: subsidiary up to EUR 300,000; 3.5 times the GOÄ; examination/biopsy costs for capsular contracture; travel costs up to EUR 300; abroad a maximum of EUR 10,000 in total, optional hospital services follow the compulsory insurance
Assumption of costs for inpatient treatment in a private clinic (not a public hospital)noup to EUR 30,000 / EUR 50,000*, payments up to the level of a flat-rate amount*up to EUR 10,000, up to EUR 5,000 if the clinic is changed**; 3.5 times the GOÄ; medication and prescription charges up to EUR 400up to EUR 10,000 with cost estimate***; up to 3.5 times the GOÄ; travel costs up to EUR 300; examination/biopsy costs for capsular contracture; abroad a maximum of EUR 10,000 in total
Assumption of costs in detail – treatments that are NOT medically necessary
Reimbursement of the costs for the restoration of the original surgical resultnoyes, privately billed up to EUR 30,000 / EUR 50,000* for all benefits*"Ästhetik Plus" module, i.e. restoration of the original surgical result insured up to EUR 10,000; medication and prescription charges up to EUR 400; up to EUR 5,000 if the doctor/clinic is changed**yes, sum insured identical to medically necessary treatments***
Reimbursement of treatments due to objective aesthetic impairmentnoyes, privately billed up to EUR 30,000 / EUR 50,000* for all benefits*"Ästhetik Plus", i.e. restoration of the original surgical result insured up to EUR 10,000, medication and prescription charges up to EUR 400; up to EUR 5,000 if the doctor/clinic is changed; "Unfall-Schutz"no, but restoration of the original surgical result insured, sum insured identical to medically necessary treatments
Benefits in the context of breast cancernosupplementary benefits for a breast reconstruction including the use of breast implants for procedures not covered by the health insurer, e.g. preventive mastectomy; waiting period 24 monthsnono
Special case of wrinkle treatmentsno special provisionno special provisionno special provisionfiller treatments: corticosteroid up to a maximum of EUR 500; further treatments up to a maximum of EUR 1,500 at 3.5 times the GOÄ; Botox/thread lifting: a maximum of EUR 1,500 at 3.5 times the GOÄ
Further points
Cover for capsular contractureif medically necessary, as a rule at grade 4grades 1 to 4grades 3 and 4grades 3 and 4
Costs of evidencing capsular contractureno (yes, if medically indicated)no (yes, if medically indicated or necessary due to objective impairment)no (yes, if medically indicated)yes, by biopsy or mammogram
Travel costsnononoup to EUR 300, if > 50 km; own car: EUR 0.30 per km, a maximum of EUR 300
Conditions for benefitscomplication during the policy termcomplication during the policy terminsured event of the complication within one year (or the period stated in the insurance policy document) after the procedure, treatment duration a maximum of 2 years, longer with the insurer's approvalcost estimate for treatment in a private clinic or private practice (not for emergency treatments); start of treatment of the complication within 3 months of notification, treatment duration a maximum of 12 months
Exclusions for complications• pre-existing conditions, but underwriting (Risikoprüfung) at application stage
• no medically clear and unexpected cause identifiable
• subjective dissatisfaction
• third-party liability (Dritthaftung)
• age-related disorder
• consequences of chronic illnesses
• pre-existing conditions, but underwriting at application stage
• no medically clear and unexpected cause identifiable
• subjective dissatisfaction
• third-party liability
• age-related disorder
• consequences of chronic illnesses
• consequences of a change in shape due to connective tissue weakness / due to dents or irregularities after liposuction (Fettabsaugung / Liposuktion)
• medical malpractice or treatment errors (Kunst- oder Behandlungsfehler)
• treatments in a country not named in the insurance policy document
• subjective dissatisfaction, but the "medassure beHappy" option
• patients with an existing diagnosis of capsular contracture: no insurability possible (according to the website, 5 June 2026)
• complications attributable to product liability
• self-inflicted injuries
• intentional acts
• capsular contracture 1 and 2
• nerve injuries
• paraesthesia
• mental illness, depression, Breast Illness Syndrome
• procedures before the start of cover
• travel costs
• medical malpractice or treatment errors
• complications that heal without medical treatment
• subjective dissatisfaction
• breast augmentation: no insurance possible for persons who have already suffered capsular contracture
• product liability (implant costs a maximum of EUR 600 if a warranty claim is rejected)
• self-inflicted injuries
• criminal offences
• capsular contracture 1 and 2
• scars
• asymmetries and deteriorations in shape; these are, however, insured where they result from a pathological change that is visually impairing
• spa treatments, sanatoriums, convalescent homes
• nerve injuries
• paraesthesia
• sensory disturbances
• numbness
• radiation damage
• blindness with eyelid lifts
• hair loss with brow lifts and facelifts
• psychological reactions
• sanctions clause
• wrinkle treatments: persons with autoimmune diseases, herpes, acne or skin inflammations, with an increased risk of blood clotting, with intolerance to hyaluronic acid, pregnant women and nursing mothers
Policyholder duties (Obliegenheiten)• the insured event must be notified without undue delay
• documents to be submitted: medical treatment, invoice or health insurer's benefits statement
• the insured event must be notified without undue delay
• documents to be submitted: medical treatment, invoice or health insurer's benefits statement
• duty to notify treatments in text form or by telephone
• submit the GKV / PKV reimbursement demand notice (Rückforderungsbescheid) without undue delay
• follow the requirements on claims settlement
• duty to notify a complication, at the latest before a procedure (in writing)
• submit a cost estimate
• notify a GKV reimbursement claim or a Beihilfe rejection without undue delay
• presentation of invoices or of the PKV / Beihilfe rejection
• assertion of warranty claims against implant manufacturers
• evidence of the grade of capsular contracture
Termination of the contractcancellation possible at the end of the month after the minimum contract period; insurer has an annual right of cancellationcancellation possible at the end of the month after the minimum contract period; insurer has an annual right of cancellationafter 12 months or as individually agreed, run-off liability (Nachhaftung) until the end of the maximum treatment duration12, 24 or 36 months after the procedure
Termination of the contract for filler treatmentfiller / Botox / thread lifting, liposuction (also for lipoedema): a maximum of 3 insured treatments within one year; 3rd treatment within one year, insurance cover for 180 days after each treatment, contract ends at the latest 180 days after the 3rd treatment
Due date of benefitsWithin one month of the benefits decision, payment then within two weeksWithin one month of the benefits decision, payment then within two weeks
Value added taxNo VAT (Mehrwertsteuer) reimbursement if the service is exempt from VAT
Basis of comparison: AVB (as at) and customer information, websiteAVB beautyprotect LITE (as at 07.2025)AVB beautyprotect PRO (as at 07.2025), AVB beautyprotect VIP (as at 07.2025)AVB medassure beauty (as at 07.2023), AUB medassure beHappy (as at 02.2024), IPID: website (as at 5 June 2026)AVB safe4beauty (as at 01.2025 DE)

*; **; ***; ****: See the footnotes to Table 1

Insuring capsular contracture correctly

Capsular contracture is the most frequent reason why complication insurance is needed: up to 20 % of all women with breast implants develop a hardening requiring treatment (Baker grade 3 or 4) within ten years – the statutory health insurer does not pay for the operation and may even reclaim costs. All the more important, then, to look at the terms and conditions: medassure beauty and safe4beauty insure only grades 3 and 4 and reject customers with existing capsular contracture; beautyprotect PRO/VIP is the only tariff that covers all Baker grades and also insures implants already in place. All the details, costs and treatment pathways in the comprehensive capsular contracture guide.

Frequently asked questions & technical terms explained simply

What is an actuary?

An actuary (Aktuar) is a state-recognised insurance mathematician. Actuaries assess risks, calculate tariffs and review the financial stability of insurance products on a mathematical basis.

What are AVB in complication insurance?

AVB stands for Allgemeine Versicherungsbedingungen, the general terms and conditions. They contain the contractual agreements between the insurer and the policyholder (Versicherungsnehmer), in particular the scope of benefits, exclusions and policyholder duties (Obliegenheiten).

What does GKV recourse (§ 52 SGB V) mean?

Anyone who has statutory health insurance (GKV) and suffers a complication after cosmetic surgery is required by law to contribute to the treatment costs – the health insurer is allowed to reclaim the money from the patient. This reclaim is called recourse (Regress). Complication insurance assumes precisely this claim, with the tariffs compared here up to EUR 300,000.

What does Regelversorgung mean?

Standard statutory care (Regelversorgung) is normal medical care via the statutory health insurer or private health insurance – that is, doctors with statutory health insurance accreditation (Kassenzulassung) and public hospitals. The opposite is private treatment outside standard statutory care, e.g. with a private doctor or in a private clinic, which you have to pay for entirely yourself.

What does "subsidiary" mean?

Subsidiary (subsidiär) means secondary: complication insurance only pays what remains after the statutory health insurer, private health insurance or civil servants' health subsidy (Beihilfe) have paid first. It therefore steps in for the gap, not for the entire invoice.

What are Obliegenheiten?

Policyholder duties (Obliegenheiten) are obligations that the insured person must fulfil in order for the insurance to pay – for example reporting a complication immediately or submitting invoices and documents. Anyone who breaches a policyholder duty risks their claim to benefits.

What is the GOÄ and the 3.5-times rate?

The GOÄ (Gebührenordnung für Ärzte, the scale of fees for doctors) determines how much doctors may charge for private treatments. Depending on the effort involved, the base price may be multiplied by a factor – up to 3.5 times the rate is customary. Some tariffs reimburse private invoices only up to this limit.

What is an Assekuradeur?

A managing general agent (Assekuradeur) is a specialised company that develops, distributes and administers an insurer's products on that insurer's behalf – effectively the link between insurer and customer. The insurance risk itself, however, is borne by the insurer behind it.

What is capsular contracture and what do the Baker grades mean?

Capsular contracture (Kapselfibrose) is the most frequent complication after a breast augmentation: the scar tissue around the implant hardens. The severity is classified in Baker grades from 1 (barely noticeable) to 4 (hard, painful, operation required). The tariffs differ considerably in which grades are insured. More on this in the capsular contracture guide.

Sources

The comparison is based on the providers' official general terms and conditions (Allgemeine Versicherungsbedingungen, AVB). The underlying documents for further reading:

📄 Full comparison as a PDF

The complete 2026 comparison test – beautyprotect LITE, PRO & VIP, medassure beauty, safe4beauty

Download PDF

Note on independence: This comparison was prepared by Gehling Consulting on the basis of the official AVB. The assessment was made exclusively according to technical criteria. As at: June 2026.